A Perfect Storm Helps Empower
Hill Centrists
By
Emily Pierce, Roll Call Staff
With
President Bush's weak approval
ratings, a shakeup in the House GOP
leadership and increasing
partisanship in Congress, House
Republican moderates have found an
unexpected opening to assert
influence on their party's agenda in
Congress - a situation they hope to
further exploit in the upcoming
election year.
Indeed, over the past year,
House GOP centrists have won
surprising victories in a
chamber that for the past decade
has been dominated by the
conservative wing of the party.
Their accomplishments last year
include getting their leadership
to acquiesce to scrapping
controversial Arctic National
Wildlife Refuge drilling
language from a crucial budget
bill and, perhaps most
stunningly, a vote in favor of
more embryonic stem-cell
research.
This year, moderates in both
chambers anticipate being big
players again during the March
and April budget battles as well
as in efforts to impose stricter
ethics rules on lobbyists and
Members of Congress, to name but
two.
"Their approach, because it is
moderate, can help the party
recover from some of the losses
[and] scandals," said Antonia
Ferrier, spokeswoman for Senate
Centrist Coalition Co-chairwoman
Olympia Snowe (R-Maine). "When
the poll numbers [for the
president and Congress] are so
bad ... it provides the ability
for us to step in and take a
much more prominent role."
While Senate GOP centrists have
long been able to influence key
pieces of legislation under
Senate rules that empower
minority factions, Rep. Mike
Castle (Del.), a prominent
member of the Tuesday Group, a
coalition of House GOP
centrists, said that House
moderates' newfound power has
come from an unusual confluence
of events.
Arguably one of the biggest
factors had to do with the
ethical and legal problems of
former House Majority Leader Tom
DeLay (R-Texas), whose decision
to step down from the No. 2
leadership position removed the
chamber's most feared enforcer
of party loyalty.
DeLay's departure, combined with
the rise of acting Majority
Leader Roy Blunt (R-Mo.) and
Chief Deputy Majority Whip Eric
Cantor (R-Va.), contributed
significantly to the moderates'
ability to influence the
legislative agenda.
"Frankly, some of the ethical
issues out there have been of
some help" in strengthening the
moderates' hand, Castle said.
Castle said that during last
year's budget battles, "There
was a real feeling that somebody
was listening to us. Before, it
was, 'Vote our way or face the
punishment.'"
A
good example came when moderates
pushed for more federal funding
of embryonic stem-cell research.
Anti-abortion conservatives have
consistently opposed such
research because they say it
results in the unnecessary
destruction of human embryos.
But with the votes of a majority
of Democrats, centrist
Republicans were able to pass
the bill out of the House last
year.
Centrists
largely credit Blunt, Cantor and
even Speaker Dennis Hastert
(R-Ill.) with calling DeLay off
a plan to whip up opposition to
the stem-cell bill. From the
beginning, when the GOP
leadership agreed to hold a vote
on the bill, the leaders pledged
not to interfere.
Similarly, moderates felt that
Blunt, as acting Majority
Leader, was more conciliatory
toward them when they threatened
to vote down the budget
reconciliation bill if it
included a controversial
provision allowing oil and
natural gas drilling in ANWR.
"DeLay clearly had a very
hard-nosed, conservative
approach to legislation," Castle
said. "I think the fact that Roy
Blunt is a listener is a plus."
An
aide to a House GOP moderate
acknowledged that the void in
leadership has played an
important role in the rise of
House Republican moderates, but
noted that moderates also
deserve credit for being "more
organized" and not trying "to
take on too much" in their
efforts to affect legislation.
Indeed, moderates chiefly
confined their battles to the
stem-cell debate and the budget
reconciliation bill, which
involved issues such as ANWR,
food stamps, Medicaid, child
support enforcement, welfare law
and other proposed cuts to
social services.
GOP centrists also credit the
heightened degree of unity among
House Democrats on tough votes
with increasing their influence,
particularly on the budget
reconciliation vote. Without
centrist Democrats to win over,
the GOP leadership had to pay
closer attention than ever to
moderate Republicans.
"With the Democrats voting as a
bloc" against the GOP
leadership, Castle said, "that
gave us an important ability to
negotiate what we wanted in
legislation."
In
the fight over oil drilling, a
cadre of House Republican
moderates were able to scuttle
plans to open ANWR. On that
issue, there historically has
been more than enough bipartisan
support in the House for opening
the refuge to drilling. In years
past, Senate GOP centrists were
often the last line of defense
against the ANWR plan, but
recent Republican gains in that
chamber gave Senate leaders
enough votes to pass the measure
under the reconciliation
process, which is protected from
filibuster.
Similarly,
House and Senate leaders' need
for centrist votes also caused
them to eliminate or scale back
some of the cuts to social
services contained in the budget
measure.
Those victories have only made
it more likely that moderates
will try to flex their muscles
again this year, particularly as
they face re-election in tough
swing districts and states. A
decline in Bush's poll numbers
last year also has made
moderates more willing to resist
White House entreaties, several
GOP centrist sources
acknowledged.
"We're
doing what we have to do to get
re-elected," said Sarah
Chamberlain Resnick, Executive
Director of the Republican Main
Street Partnership, a group of
House and Senate moderates.
Chamberlain Resnick noted that
bribery and lobbying scandals
surrounding several Republican
Members threaten to taint the
entire party in the minds of the
electorate.
"A lot of that will be used
against us because we are
Republicans," she said. "You
can't allow Democrats to use all
the bad news about Republicans
... against you."
As
a result, moderate Republicans
will continue to map voting
strategies that may be
substantially different from
what the president or House GOP
leaders are pushing.
"On
virtually every issue, moderates
are going to be asking
themselves, 'Should I be for
this issue or not?'" Castle
said.
Unlike their House
counterparts, the power wielded
by Senate GOP centrists has not
changed much over the past year.
"I
don't see any more teeth behind
their bark. It's just a loud
bark," said one senior Senate
GOP aide.
However, the handful of
moderates in that chamber still
have had a big hand in limiting
the conservative bent of
legislation coming out of the
Senate, and several of them
joined together with Sen. John
McCain (R-Ariz.) and centrist
Democrats in early 2005 to form
the "Gang of 14" that prevented
Majority Leader Bill Frist (R-Tenn.)
from ending the minority's
ability to filibuster judicial
nominations.
"It's still developing - the
strength of the moderates," said
Sen. Lincoln Chafee (R-R.I.).
"We have opportunities to stick
together, but different issues
pull us in different directions.
I'm always skeptical of our
ability to stay cohesive."
But
as in the past, centrists in
both chambers expect to come
together this year on budget
issues and are holding out the
possibility that they'll be even
more reluctant to support deep
cuts to social services.
The
aide to a House Republican
moderate said that House
centrists can be expected join
conservatives in reviving
attempts to give rank-and-file
Members added power to oppose
"pork barrel" projects in
appropriations bills. A similar
effort failed last year.
Ferrier noted that Snowe and
other GOP centrists would likely
push for some changes to the
Medicare prescription drug
program, which got off to a
rocky start at the beginning of
this year.
Ferrier also predicted that
"there are going to be more
fissures in the party on the
amount of authority" for the
president, given recent
questions over the president's
decision to circumvent the
courts in ordering the National
Security Agency to spy on
Americans suspected of ties to
overseas terrorists.